Sump Pump Not Working? Causes, Quick Checks and When to Call
Sump Pump Not Working? Causes, Quick Checks and When to Call

If your sump pump has stopped working, start with power, then the float, then the discharge line and check valve. Most failures trace back to one of those four. If the pit is filling and the pump will not move it, do not wait: water in a basement spreads fast, and a pump that is more than about 10 years old is usually cheaper to replace than to keep chasing. We are a Port Coquitlam plumbing company, and if the checks below do not get the pump moving, call us any hour and Jon will come out.
TL;DR
- Check power first: breaker, GFCI outlet, plug and cord. A pump that will not start is most often an electrical problem.
- A pump that hums or runs but moves no water usually has a blocked intake, an air lock, a stuck check valve or a damaged impeller.
- A pump that never shuts off, or short cycles, points to a stuck float switch or water flowing back through the check valve.
- Federal guidance says to replace sump pumps about every 10 years and test them fully once a year.
- Damaged wiring, a dead outlet or a pump that will not run with water in the pit is a job for a licensed trade, not a DIY fix.
Table of Contents
- How a sump pump works, in one minute
- Safe checks to run first
- Match the symptom to the likely cause
- The pump will not turn on
- The pump runs but no water leaves the pit
- The pump runs constantly or cycles too often
- What happens if you leave it
- Repair or replace?
- Keep it from failing again
- Why it is worth calling the owner
- When to call us
- FAQ
- Sources
How a sump pump works, in one minute
Knowing the parts makes the failures easy to read. According to Canada.ca, groundwater collects in the pit (the sump) from your weeping tile, the perforated pipe around the foundation. As the water rises, a float triggers a switch, and the pump pushes water out through a discharge pipe. A check valve on that pipe stops water from running back into the pit.
So there are really five things that can fail: the power, the float switch, the pump itself (motor and impeller, the spinning part that moves the water), the check valve and the discharge line. The same federal page lists the usual reasons a pump stops working: water entering the pit too fast, float switch problems, poor maintenance of the pump or pipe, a unit at the end of its life, or a power outage.
Safe checks to run first
These are inspection steps only. Never open an outlet or go into the electrical panel, and never reach into a pit with the pump plugged in.
- Look at the pit. Is water at or above the level where the pump should start? If the pit is nearly dry, the pump may simply have nothing to do. Zoeller Canada lists a water level below the trigger point as one reason a pump will not turn on.
- Check the breaker and the outlet. A tripped breaker, blown fuse or dead outlet is a common cause. Zoeller recommends a GFCI outlet that is not controlled by a wall switch. Press the test and reset buttons on the GFCI to see whether it is live.
- Check the plug and cord. The plug should be fully seated and the cord undamaged. Pentair says the most common cause of sump pump failure is electrical, and recommends plugging the pump straight into an outlet, with no extension cord, on a circuit that powers nothing else.
- Unplug the pump, then check the float. Clear sediment and debris from around it and make sure it moves freely through its full range. A float caught on the pit wall or on debris is a frequent culprit.
- Run a bucket test. Plug the pump back in and pour water slowly into the pit. The pump should start within seconds, empty the pit and shut off. The Toronto-area guidance we reviewed suggests about 20 litres, and Canada.ca’s maintenance advice is to confirm the pit empties and that water is directed out.
- Check the outside end. Go outside while the pump runs and confirm water is leaving the discharge pipe.
If the pump fails any step after power is confirmed, or you find damaged wiring or a dead receptacle, stop there.
Match the symptom to the likely cause
| What you see | Likely cause | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Pump does not start, pit is full | Tripped breaker, dead GFCI, unplugged cord, stuck float, failed motor | Check power and float; if still dead, call a licensed trade |
| Pump runs or hums, little or no water leaves | Blocked intake, air lock, stuck or backwards check valve, damaged impeller, blocked discharge | Unplug, check intake and discharge; call if it persists |
| Pump never shuts off | Stuck or damaged float switch | Free the float; replace the switch or pump if it stays stuck |
| Pump starts and stops too often | Water falling back through the check valve, or a sticking float | Inspect the check valve and float |
| Pump works only if you nudge the float | Failing float switch | Plan a repair or replacement |
| Loud grinding, rattling or burning smell | Worn bearings or damaged impeller | Unplug it and have it replaced |
The pump will not turn on
Start with the electrical checks above. If the outlet is live and the pit has water, the float is the next suspect. Pentair says the float switch is typically the first part to fail. NDSU Extension also names worn or rusted motor bearings and a float switch with poor electrical contact as common reasons pumps quit.
One warning for anyone tempted to bypass the float with a piggyback plug to test the motor: Pentair says to do it only for a few minutes, so the pump does not overheat. If the motor does not run even then, the pump is finished.
If the pump will not run with water in the pit, or the outlet is dead, that is the point to stop. The wiring behind a dead outlet is not a homeowner job. Call us: we handle the plumbing side, and electrical work is something we offer through a subcontracted add-on, so you do not have to line up two trades during a flooding night. You can see that on our electrical services page.

The pump runs but no water leaves the pit
This is the one that feels most alarming, because you can hear the motor working while the water level stays put. Zoeller Canada lists these causes:
- a check valve installed backwards
- a clogged shut-off valve
- a blocked impeller or inlet
- an air lock in the discharge pipe
- a lift height that is too great for the pump
The owner’s manual for a Canadian Tire sump pump gives the same pattern: a pump that runs but moves little water usually has a blocked screen, debris in the impeller or discharge, or a loose or broken impeller.
An air lock happens when trapped air keeps the impeller from pushing water up the pipe. Pentair’s fix is a small anti-airlock hole, 1/16 to 1/8 inch, drilled in the discharge pipe above the pump and below the check valve. That is a modification to the pipe, so if you are not comfortable making it, leave it to a plumber.
A check valve should have an arrow showing flow direction, pointing away from the pump. If it is backwards or stuck shut, water cannot leave.
A blocked discharge line is common in cold weather. The Edmonton sump pump maintenance guide warns that a discharge line can freeze and block in freezing weather, and says outside hoses should be disconnected before winter. In the Tri-Cities freezing nights are less frequent than on the Prairies, but a cold snap after a wet fall is exactly when a pump is working hardest.

If it runs and the level does not drop after you have cleared the intake and confirmed the discharge is open, the impeller or the pump is likely damaged. Oil in the pit can point to a failed seal, and strange motor noises usually mean worn parts. Both are replacement signs.
The pump runs constantly or cycles too often
A pump that never stops is also “not working”, and it wears itself out. NDSU’s guidance and Zoeller both point to a stuck or damaged float switch for a pump that never shuts off. Short cycling, where the pump starts and stops over and over, tends to mean water is falling back through a faulty check valve, or the float is sticking. An unsecured pump on a flexible hose can also shift and interfere with its own switch, according to the manual above.
High groundwater after heavy rain can make a healthy pump run a lot, which is normal. If it runs hard in dry weather, something is wrong. We cover that case in detail in why a sump pump runs constantly, and you can browse more sump pump repair articles from our team.
On the question of running a pump with no water in the pit: NDSU Extension states that briefly running a dry pump will not do any damage. It is a short test, not a way to leave it.
What happens if you leave it
When the pump is not working, South Dakota State Extension explains, water builds up in the sump and the basement is at risk of flooding. If the drainage around the foundation is also plugged or crushed, water can build up outside and come in through walls, floors or the joint where the floor meets the wall.
The practical rule: if the pit is full and the pump is not moving it, treat it as urgent. Move anything valuable off the floor, keep away from outlets and the panel if water is spreading, and call. If the water that comes up is not groundwater but sewage coming from drains, that is a different problem, covered in our guide to sewer backup in your basement.
Repair or replace?
Age decides most of this. Canada.ca says sump pumps should generally be replaced every 10 years, subject to the manufacturer’s recommendations, and tested fully once a year.
A simple way to think about it:
- Under 5 years old, with a clear cause. A stuck float, blocked intake, backwards check valve or tripped circuit is a cheap fix. Repair.
- 7 to 10 years old. The pump may still run, but it is near the end of its service life. If it has failed once already, replacing it is the sounder choice.
- Over 10 years old, or with a seized motor, worn bearings, a damaged impeller or a failed seal. Replace it.
We do not publish a fixed price for this work, because the right quote depends on the pump, the pit and the discharge route. Jon gives quotes on site, so you see the actual conditions before you agree to anything.
Keep it from failing again
Six habits cover most of what causes failures, based on Canada.ca and the Canadian sources above:
- Test it once a year at minimum. Check it during and after heavy rainfall, rapid snowmelt and power outages too.
- Check the check valve and the discharge line are clear and working.
- Plan for outages. Because the pump depends on electricity, federal guidance calls for an alternate power source and a backup pump. A backup on the same circuit gives no protection when the power is out. Wawanesa also suggests a water-level alarm and a backup generator, since outages are a main cause of failure.
- Keep it on its own circuit, plugged straight in, no extension cord.
- Send water away from the house. Canada.ca says the discharge should be at least 1.5 m (5 ft) from the foundation if possible. SDSU Extension warns against discharging into a municipal sewer or septic field.
- Keep the pit clean. Silt and debris jam floats and impellers.
Why it is worth calling the owner
A sump pump failure is rarely just a pump problem. It involves power, piping, valves and where the water goes. When someone shows up, you want one person who looks at the whole chain and tells you plainly what it needs. That is how we work: Jon is the technician on site, not a crew you have never met.
Our view on sump pump failures
Most of the sump pump calls people dread start the same way: the pump was fine last month, nobody tested it, and it fails on the wettest night of the year. The fix is rarely dramatic. It is a float that stuck, a check valve that was put in backwards, a pump that was past its time.
What we have learned from 20 years in the trade is that the quickest repair is the honest one. If a pump needs a ten-minute fix, we tell you. If it is at the end of its life, we tell you that too and quote the replacement on site, before any work starts. We are an owner-led company, so the person who gives you the diagnosis is the person who does the job and stands behind it.
If you are in Port Coquitlam, Coquitlam or Port Moody and the pit is filling, call. We answer 24 hours a day.
Jon
When to call us
Call as soon as the pit is filling and the pump is not clearing it, or if you find a dead outlet, damaged wiring or a pump that will not run with water in the pit. We serve homeowners, strata properties and property managers across the Tri-Cities and Metro Vancouver, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, through our 24/7 emergency plumbing line. Our call-out fee is $60, and it is waived if the work goes ahead. Quotes are given on site.

If you manage a strata or rental building with several units, tell us when you call. Our plumbing services cover building plumbing as well as individual homes, and a quick response matters more when one pump protects many suites.
FAQ
Why is my sump pump running but not pumping water?
The usual causes are a blocked intake or screen, an air lock in the discharge pipe, a check valve that is stuck or installed backwards, a damaged impeller, or a blocked discharge line. Unplug the pump before checking the intake. If water still does not move once those are clear, the pump itself is likely worn out.
What are the signs of sump pump failure?
The main signs are a pump that will not start with water in the pit, one that hums or runs without lowering the level, one that never shuts off or cycles on and off rapidly, and loud grinding or rattling. A pit that stays full after rain is the clearest warning. A bucket test each year shows problems before a storm does.
How long does a sump pump last?
Canada.ca says to replace sump pumps generally every 10 years, depending on the manufacturer’s recommendations. Heat shortens motor life, according to Pentair, so a pump that works hard every wet season may need replacing sooner.
Can I fix a sump pump myself?
You can safely inspect it: check the breaker and GFCI, free the float, clear debris with the pump unplugged and run a bucket test. Anything involving wiring, a dead outlet or a pump that will not run with water in the pit should go to a licensed trade.
Sources
- Sump pumps, Canada.ca
- 4 Common Sump Pump Problems (And How to Fix Them), Zoeller Canada
- Sump Pump Troubleshooting FAQ, Pentair
- Sump pump owner’s manual, Canadian Tire
- Flooding and Sump Pumps, South Dakota State Extension
- Check Your Sump Pump, NDSU Extension
- Sump Pump Guide, Edmonton maintenance and replacement guide
- Sump pump basics, Wawanesa Canada
